The
manga has sold more than 20 million copies in Japan; individual volumes
frequently appeared on top ten lists of best-selling manga there (see
table). Individual volumes have appeared in Diamond Comic Distributors's
lists of 300 best-selling graphic novels in North America several
times. In 2011, the Japanese website Ameba conducted a "Top 10" online
web poll of the "Best Shōnen Jump Manga of the 21st Century" and
Eyeshield 21 was placed seventh, although in another poll of the best
Shōnen Jump titles that the readers nonetheless did not want to continue
reading, Cosplay Costumes Eyeshield 21 ranked twentieth. The anime adaptation was
also featured several times in Japanese television rankings, with the
first episode having a 7.5 percent television viewership rating. In
2006, Japanese television network TV Asahi conducted a poll for the top
hundred anime, and Eyeshield 21 was placed 47th.[128] Moreover,
Eyeshield 21's series is credited with increasing the number of Japanese
teenagers playing American football.
Critics have generally
given the Eyeshield 21 manga positive reviews. Deb Aoki from About.com
wrote that tying with Bleach, Eyeshield 21 was the best continuing
shōnen manga of 2007, because it "has well-written characters, dynamic
artwork, nail-biting cliffhangers, plus a winning mix of comedy, action
and drama". On the 2008 list, Aoki listed Eyeshield 21 as the best
continuing shōnen, as it was able to "[come] into its own" from other
shōnen series. In that same year, Pop Culture Shock's Sam Kusek elected
it the best continuing manga series. Jarred Pine from Mania.com praised
the humor and how the creators "bring out the energy and excitement of
the game for the readers". Eyeshield 21 Costumes June Shimonishi reviewing for School Library
Journal, wrote that it "delivers a fresh and entertaining take on all
the standard sports clichés". She also said that its art is "superb ...
with every inch filled with details and no gag left unseen".[136] Zac
Bertschy from Anime News Network (ANN) declared Eyeshield 21 "defies
convention" by turning what most might consider "a really ridiculously
bad idea" into "something most everyone would be able to enjoy".Carlo
Santos from ANN called it a "typical sports story", writing that what
make it an above average series are its characters and artwork. He also
wrote that people who think American football is boring "may change
their minds after seeing the action sequences in Eyeshield 21."[138]
Later, however, Santos said, "[a] lot of familiar clichés show
themselves" in Eyeshield 21, and that "[t]he storyline also does a
sloppy job of keeping track of the game ... making it even less
believable than it already is".
No comments:
Post a Comment